Li-S Batteries: Energy density two to three times higher

[Sparty]

The Evolution of Battery Technology: Li-S Energy's BNNT Innovation in Lithium-Sulfur Batteries
In the rapidly evolving landscape of energy storage, lithium-sulfur (Li-S) batteries are emerging as a promising next-generation technology that could revolutionize sectors from aviation to defense.

Australian company Li-S Energy is at the forefront of this innovation, particularly through their novel integration of boron nitride nanotubes (BNNT) in battery design.
The Promise of Lithium-Sulfur Technology

Lithium-sulfur batteries offer several significant advantages over traditional lithium-ion technologies,
including a theoretical energy density two to three times higher than current commercial batteries.

This technology utilizes abundant, cost-effective sulfur, potentially reducing production costs while delivering improved performance in cold temperatures.

When compared to lithium iron phosphate (LFP) batteries, Li-S technology shows particular promise for specialized applications. While LFP batteries dominate the electric vehicle and grid storage markets due to their proven reliability and safety, Li-S batteries are positioning themselves for applications where maximum energy density is crucial, such as aviation and aerospace.

Li-S Energy's Strategic Position
According to their recent financial reports, Li-S Energy maintains a strong financial position with $22.8 million in cash and cash equivalents as of FY2024. The company has outlined four strategic objectives for the next two years:

Establishing core revenue through test cell development and battery pack innovation
Diversifying funding streams through government grants and new products
Developing strong partnerships with conditional offtake agreements
Creating a pathway to scale with a planned 500MWh facility

The BNNT Innovation
Li-S Energy's key technological differentiation lies in their integration of boron nitride nanotubes. This innovation addresses several critical challenges in Li-S battery technology:

Polysulfide containment: BNNT acts as a physical barrier to prevent polysulfide shuttling, a common failure mechanism in Li-S batteries

Enhanced conductivity: Improves electron transport and power performance
Structural stability: Manages sulfur volume changes during cycling
Temperature performance: Provides high thermal stability across a wide temperature range

Market Applications and Future Outlook
The company is targeting specific market segments where the high energy density of Li-S batteries provides crucial advantages:

Aviation and aerospace (partnering with magniX)
Defense applications
High-altitude drones and UAVs
Specialized industrial applications

With plans for commercialization in 2025 and support from Australia's National Battery Strategy and Battery Breakthrough Initiative, Li-S Energy is positioning itself as a key player in the next generation of battery technology.

Challenges and Considerations
Despite the promising advances, several challenges remain:

Scaling BNNT production while managing costs
Integration into manufacturing processes
Material availability and supply chain considerations
Achieving competitive cycle life compared to established technologies

Conclusion
Li-S Energy's innovative approach to lithium-sulfur battery technology, particularly through BNNT integration, represents a significant step forward in addressing the limitations of traditional Li-S batteries. As the company moves toward commercialization in 2025, their success could mark a crucial advancement in high-energy-density battery applications, particularly in aviation and defense sectors.

Note: This article synthesizes information from Li-S Energy's corporate communications and general industry knowledge. Technical specifications and company plans are subject to change as the technology develops.

[Sparty]

Energy Density:

Lithium Sulfur (Li-S):

Theoretical specific energy: ~2,567 Wh/kg
Practical specific energy achieved so far: ~400-600 Wh/kg

LFP (LiFePO4):

Theoretical specific energy: ~500-600 Wh/kg
Practical specific energy: ~90-160 Wh/kg

Sources I've seen quote slightly different numbers, and there's often confusion between theoretical maximum and practical achieved values. The key point remains valid that Li-S has higher theoretical energy density than LFP.

This is a key potential advantage for Li-S in aviation/aerospace

Cost:

Li-S: Potentially cheaper due to abundant sulfur
LFP: Already relatively low-cost compared to other Li-ion chemistries
Both avoid expensive cobalt

Safety:

Li-S: Generally considered safe, lower risk of thermal runaway
LFP: Extremely safe, very stable chemistry
Both are among the safer battery chemistries

Cycle Life:

Li-S: Currently limited (typically hundreds of cycles) due to polysulfide shuttle effect
LFP: Excellent (thousands of cycles)
This is a major current advantage for LFP

Commercial Status:

Li-S: Still largely in development/early commercialization
LFP: Mature technology, widely deployed
LFP is currently dominating many markets including EVs

Temperature Performance:

Li-S: Better in cold conditions
LFP: Some limitations in extreme temperatures
Li-S has potential advantages for certain climates

Main Applications:

Li-S: Targeting aviation, defense, high-energy applications
LFP: EVs, grid storage, marine applications
Different market focus based on characteristics

[Sparty]

Main applications for both battery types:

Lithium Sulfur (Li-S):

Aviation/Aerospace

Electric aircraft (e.g. Li-S Energy's work with magniX)
High-altitude drones/UAVs
Satellites (due to high energy density)


Defense/Military

Portable soldier equipment
Military drones
Specialized vehicles


Specialty Applications

Deep-sea equipment (performs well in cold)
Remote sensing
Scientific instruments



LiFePO4 (LFP):

Electric Vehicles

Tesla using in standard range models
BYD's entire fleet
Electric buses
E-bikes and scooters


Stationary Storage

Home battery systems
Grid-scale storage
Solar integration
Backup power


Industrial

Forklifts
Marine applications
Telecom backup
UPS systems



Key Difference in Applications:

LFP: Used where safety, cost, and longevity are priorities
Li-S: Targeted at applications where maximum energy density is crucial
LFP: Mass market, established
Li-S: Currently specialized/niche markets

[Sparty]

The use of boron nitride nanotubes (BNNT) in Li-S battery design offers several key advantages:
Core Benefits:

Polysulfide Containment

Acts as a physical barrier to prevent polysulfide shuttling
Helps maintain capacity over more cycles
Reduces one of Li-S batteries' main failure mechanisms


Enhanced Conductivity

Improves electron transport through the cathode
Better power performance
More efficient charging/discharging


Structural Stability

Helps manage sulfur volume changes during cycling
Maintains electrode integrity
Reduces mechanical degradation


Temperature Performance

High thermal stability
Good performance across wider temperature range
Enhanced safety characteristics



Technical Advantages:

High surface area for sulfur loading
Strong mechanical properties
Chemical inertness
Thermal conductivity

Challenges:

BNNT production costs
Scale-up complexity
Integration into manufacturing processes
Material availability

The key innovation from Li-S Energy is combining BNNT with their Li-S chemistry to address the traditional limitations of Li-S batteries, particularly cycle life and stability. However, successfully scaling this technology while managing costs remains a key challenge for commercialization.

[Sparty]

2024 was the year that Li-S Energy transitioned from a research-led battery business to a customer
and engineering-led manufacturer.

https://onlinereports.irmau.com/2024/LIS/4/